Wednesday, April 30, 2008

Conscience




(Above-The cramped basement where Elisabeth and 3 kids were imprisoned; Below-Josef Fritzl; Lowest-His daughter Elisabeth at age 11)

'Conscience' is defined by Wikipedia as 'a hypothesised ability or faculty that distinguishes whether our actions are right or wrong. It leads to feelings of remorse when we do things that go against our moral values, and to feelings of rectitude or integrity when our actions conform to our moral values. It is also the attitude which informs our moral judgment before performing any action.'

By this definition, we can safely conclude that most of humanity has lost the responsibility, the essential sense of morality, that a conscience ensures.

Most of us are now aware of the 'Horror House' in Austria, where 73-year-old Josef Fritzl imprisoned his daughter Elisabeth for 24 long years in a windowless basement, locked with an electronic code. In a chillingly cold case of incest, he bore seven children by her. The former electrician, the perpetrator of this tragedy that transgresses all boundaries, reportedly said that he was 'sorry' for his family, and that he just wanted to be left alone.

Which, to me, is an incredible thing. In his quiet moments, doesn't the merciless pain he inflicted upon his hapless daughter torture him? How does his conscience allow him to sleep nights? Don't his thoughts and nightmares rankle with the corpse of the baby-HIS baby-that he incinerated in an oven? How could his wife and six of Elisabeth's siblings not have known what was happening? It has come to light that Josef first sexually assaulted Elisabeth when she was 11, precipitating her desperate attempts to run away from home at the ages of 16 and 18. Ultimately, her father lured her to her new 'home', a basement with a concrete door, devoid of natural light, hope or happiness. A place where she birthed seven children by a monster, without anyone knowing or caring. Josef claimed that she had run away with a religious sect, and made three of his illegitimate children(or grandchildren?) appear on his doorstep. The other three children were forced to live in the dingy room with their mother. It is impossible to empathise with what they must've suffered, and witnessed-rapes and beatings instead of school and games. I find it laughable that no one realised what was going on-Josef's wife, his family, his neighbours. Or did they turn the other cheek? That is more probable.

On a smaller scale, my mother and I went shopping the other day. We saw an old, shrivelled lady, standing near the shop, dressed well but not extravagantly. She did not seem well to do, her hands were twitching with nervousness and she appeared lost; she wasn't a beggar. She pleaded with us to help her and narrated her tale of woe-robbed of her purse, she was in a strange city with no food and no way to meet her son who lived here. Pitying her, my mother gave her money. When I looked back again, there was no sign of the woman. Her seemingly frail vulnerability had just been a phenomenal piece of acting.

Sigh.

In the fairytales everything is so perfect. In the movies. In all stories. Daddies kiss their little girls goodnight and little old ladies bake fragrant cakes and never lie because they are God fearing souls. In real life, incest is more common than most people believe it is and nothing is what it seems.

Reality is so disappointing. Painful. Cruel. Harsh. And oh yeah, real.

6 comments:

arun said...

yeah .. reality is often disturbing. yet , it clearly is inescapable . the only thing that we can do is to believe in a certain higher justice .. cuz if we take everything into our hands, there certainly is no hope .

The Armchair Philosopher said...

Statisticians would go crazy with the number of cases of incest in the subcontinent itself. Living in a land populated by sadists violating mothers, daughters and sisters (don't forget sisters-in-law), the Austrian case is just one of the few that have been revealed to the public eye. A lack of conscience (or maybe, the presence of a different idea of 'conscience') is deemed to be the cause of such acts, but i disagree. There are 3 kinds of people on the earth: the first, are those who want to do stuff, but are afraid of the consequences, the second, are those who disregard laws (meant to contain those coming under the first category) and do what they want to. It is the need for the third category, the ones who really know what it is, to be rational, human and moral, that is felt.

Anand said...

I really wish the guy spends the rest of his years in the most inhumane, inhospitable conditions deviod of proper air, light and sanitation. Gee... the moment I saw this on BBC, I was shocked! He must die in a pool of his own excreta... be denied water to the extent of drinking his own fluids.... UGH!!!

The Usurper said...

hmmm, anand an eye for an eye turns the whole world blind.. if u ask me he shld be locked into a big gigantic room with all that he didnt allow his daughter.. everything sunlight, sickeningly rich food i mean disgustingly sickening rich food, but all by himself with no contact with the outside world.. there can be no worse torture than the guilt that'll kill him.. but dont provide anything he can hang himself with. sounds wierd but yeah its one one of the worst imprisonments possible and bout that lady iv seen this guy near coll hus told me the same story in pretty good english of his mom bein admitted to nimhans and him not havin money to go take her to the village 3 times! same story same guy...

Ananyaa said...

I dont think anyone can come up with a punishment for what he did.It's futile.And punishing him doesnt really change the equation.
Its kind of annoying to listen to some opinionated 17 year olds declaring a punishment for a man who sinned.

Marte said...

Beautiful Megs! Love your stories. And I can totally understand everything you think.

But I did read a story the other day of an old lady who told a similar story. She also never knew her husband had abused her daughter and her duaghter even had a baby. I don't think the woman should be the one blamed here. Some women aren't that (i don't know the right word..) confident and sometimes their husband is really overpowering. I think she should have noticed too, but I think there is a big possibility that she genuinly didn't notice.

And he's sick, no doubt. He disgusts me.